Thursday, 5 November 2015

True and False Reform in the Church - 8 principles



Avery Cardinal Dulles, S.J. wrote a very interesting article about ten years ago, published in First Things.

It was essentially a review of a book written more than a decade before Vatican II by the French Dominican, Yves Congar with the title True and False Reform in the Church.

Drawing to some degree on Congar’s work, Cardinal Dulles suggested a number of principles by which reform proposals in our day might be assessed.  Below is an extract from his article:

1) According to Congar, “the great law of a Catholic reformism will be to begin with a return to the principles of Catholicism.” Vatican II, echoing his words, taught that “every renewal of the Church essentially consists in an increase of fidelity to her own calling” (UR 6).
Catholicism derives its principles from God by way of revelation. The most authoritative guidance comes from Holy Scripture understood in the light of apostolic tradition, inasmuch as this is the normative channel whereby revelation is transmitted. In his reform of the liturgy, Pius X issued a call to return to the sources (Revertimini ad fontes). Pius XII declared that speculation becomes sterile if it neglects to return continually to the sacred sources of Scripture and tradition, which contain inexhaustible treasures of truth.
 
2) Any reform conducted in the Catholic spirit will respect the Church’s styles of worship and pastoral life. It will be content to operate within the Church’s spiritual and devotional heritage, with due regard for her Marian piety, her devotion to the saints, her high regard for the monastic life and the vows of religion, her penitential practices, and her eucharistic worship. A truly Catholic reform will not fanatically insist on the sheer logic of an intellectual system but will take account of concrete possibilities of the situation, seeking to work within the framework of the given.

3) A genuinely Catholic reform will adhere to the fullness of Catholic doctrine, including not only the dogmatic definitions of popes and councils, but doctrines constantly and universally held as matters pertaining to the faith. In this connection cognizance will be taken of the distinction made by Vatican II between the deposit of faith and the formulations of doctrine. Because human thought and language are inevitably affected by cultural and historical factors, it may be necessary from time to time to adjust the language in which the faith has been proclaimed. Repeated in a new situation, the old formulations can often be misleading, as instanced by the examples of Baius and Jansenius in the seventeenth century. These scholars quoted Augustine to the letter but did not take account of the changed meaning of his words.
 
4) True reform will respect the divinely given structures of the Church, including the differences of states of life and vocations. Not all are equipped by training and office to pronounce on the compatibility of new theories and opinions with the Church’s faith. This function is, in fact, reserved to the hierarchical magisterium, though the advice of theologians and others will normally be sought.
 
5) A reform that is Catholic in spirit will seek to maintain communion with the whole body of the Church, and will avoid anything savoring of schism or factionalism. St. Paul speaks of anger, dissension, and party spirit as contrary to the Spirit of God (Galatians 5:20). To be Catholic is precisely to see oneself as part of a larger whole, to be inserted in the Church universal.

6) Reformers will have to exercise the virtue of patience, often accepting delays. Congar finds Luther especially lacking in this virtue. But even Luther, stubborn and unyielding though he often was, cautioned his disciple Andreas Karlstadt on the importance of proceeding slowly, so as not to offend simple believers who were unprepared for changes that were objectively warranted. Prudent reformers will recognize that they themselves stand under correction, and that their proposals, even if valid, may be premature. As Newman reminded his readers, there is such a thing as a good idea whose time has not yet come. Depending on the circumstances, Church authorities may wisely delay its acceptance until people’s imaginations become accustomed to the innovation.
 
7) As a negative criterion, I would suggest that a valid reform must not yield to the tendencies of our fallen nature, but must rather resist them. Under color of reform, we are sometimes tempted to promote what flatters our pride and feeds our self-interest, even though the gospel counsels humility and renunciation. Persons who have prestige, influence, and power usually want to retain and increase these; those who lack them want to acquire them. Both groups must undergo conversion.

8) For similar reasons we must be on guard against purported reforms that are aligned with the prevailing tendencies in secular society. One thinks in this connection of the enormous harm done in early modern times by nationalism in religion, a major factor contributing to the divisions of the Reformation era and to the enfeeblement of the Catholic Church during the Enlightenment. The liturgical and organizational reforms of Joseph II in Austria, the Civil Constitution on the Clergy enacted in France in 1790, the extreme liberalism of Félicité de Lamennais early in the nineteenth century, and the evolutionary religion of the Modernists at the dawn of the twentieth century ” all these movements afford examples of initiatives perfectly attuned to the spirit of their times but antithetical to the true character of Catholic Christianity.
 
In our day the prevailing climate of agnosticism, relativism, and subjectivism is frequently taken as having the kind of normative value that belongs by right to the word of God. We must energetically oppose reformers who contend that the Church must abandon her claims to absolute truth, must allow dissent from her own doctrines, and must be governed according to the principles of liberal democracy.

False reforms, I conclude, are those that fail to respect the imperatives of the gospel and the divinely given traditions and structures of the Church, or which impair ecclesial communion and tend rather toward schism. Would-be reformers often proclaim themselves to be prophets, but show their true colors by their lack of humility, their impatience, and their disregard for the Sacred Scripture and tradition.

7 comments:

  1. BEST ONLINE LOVE SPELL CASTER TO GET YOUR EX LOVER, HUSBAND, WIFE, GIRLFRIEND OR BOYFRIEND BACK. ADD HIM UP ON WHATSAPP: +2348144172934
    How I Got My Ex Husband Back........... I am jessica roma by name. Greetings to every one that is reading this testimony. I have been rejected by my husband after three(3) years of marriage just because another woman had a spell on him and he left me and the kid to suffer. one day when i was reading through the web, i saw a post on how this spell caster on this address dr.ojokaspelltemple@gmail.com , have help a woman to get back her husband and i gave him a reply to his address and he told me that a woman had a spell on my husband and he told me that he will help me and after 24hours that i will have my husband back. i believed him and today i am glad to let you all know that this spell caster have the power to bring lovers back. because i am now happy with my husband. Thanks for Dr. ojoka . His email: dr.ojokaspelltemple@gmail.com or whatsApp him +2348144172934 check is website
    http://drojokaspelltemple.website2.me/love-spell
    (4)If you want to have a child.
    (5)You want to be protected spiritually.
    (6)Help bringing people out of prison
    (7)Lottery power ball
    Whatsapp or call +2348144172934 (please Ignore if you don't need help)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dr.ben the best spell caster online restore my broken relationship and i highly recommends Dr.ben to anyone in need of help!
    My husband left me for another woman 3 months ago and ever since then my life have been filled with pains sorrow and heart break because he was my first love whom i have spent my entire life with. A friend of mine told me he saw some testimonies of a spell caster called Dr ben that he can bring back lover within some few days, i laugh it out and said i am not interested but because of the love my friend had for me, she consulted the great priest on my behalf and to my greatest surprise after 2 days my husband called me for the very first time after three months that he is missing me and that he is so sorry for every thing he made me went through.He came back to me and now we are happy together. I still can’t believe it, because it highly unbelievable. Thank you Dr.ben for bringing back my lover and also to my lovely friend who interceded on my behalf, for any one who might need the help of this great priest here is the email address: drbenspellcaster@gmail.com , you can also call him or add him on Whats-app: +2348151642717…

    ReplyDelete
  3. GET YOUR PROBLEM SOLVE TODAY WITH MY PROFESSION IN ANY SPIRITUAL SPELL, MY NAME IS PRIEST  OKEKE, AND THIS IS MY WHATSAPP   +  (EMAIL: profokeke7@gmail.com)
    ,I LIVE IN SOUTH AFRICA , AM ALWAYS AVAILABLE TO RENDER YOU HELP. WITH EXPERIENCE OF 80 YEARS IN SPELL CASTING AND HERBAL MEDICINE TO CURE ANY KIND OF DISEASE THAT YOU MAY HAVE, CONTACT ME ON ANY KIND OF ISSUES YOU MAY HAVE THAT IS BOTHERING YOU I CAN HELP YOU SOLVE PROBLEMS AS LISTED BELOW:www.onlinelovespells.com
    Whatsapp   +256758348477 
    (1) If you want your Divorced Husband/Wife back.
    (2) If you want your Ex Boyfriend/Girlfriend back.
    (3) If you always have Bad Dreams and you don't know the interpretations.
    (4) You want to be Promoted in your Office.
    (5) You want Women/Men to run after you.
    (6) If you want Children of your choice.
    (7) You want to be Rich Forever.
    (8) You want to tie your Husband/Wife to be yours forever.
    (9) Or you have been scammed and you want to Recover your Lost Money.
    (10) If you are in Love with Someone and you want Him/Her to fall in Love with you Totally.
    (12) If you want a Tame my Lover Spell.
    (13) If you want a Make Me Sexy Spell.
    (14) If you want a STOP His Roving Eyes Spell.
    (15) If you want a Rejuvenated Love Spell.
    (16) If you want a Be Faithful To Me Spell.
    (17) If you want to prevent or keep others from talking about my man.
    (18) Remove Bad Spells from Homes, Business & Customer Attraction etc.
    (19) Stop your Marriage or Relationship from Breaking Apart.
    (20) Read all your problems before you even mention them to me.
    (21) Remove the Back Spot that keeps on taking your Money Away.
    (22) Find out why you are not progressing in Life and the Solution.
    (23) Eliminate in family fights.
    (24) Ensure Excellent School Grades even for Children with Mental Disabilities.
    (25) Get promotion you have Desired for a Long Time at Work or in your Career.
    (26) Heal Barrenness in Women and Disturbing Menstruation.
    (27) Get you marriage to the Lover of your Choice.
    (28) Guarantee you Win the Troubling Court Cases.
    (39) Get the Spell to Win a Lottery.
    (30) Diabetes Cure and Remedy.
    (31) Herpes Cure and Remedy.
    (32) Hepatitis A, B, C Cure and Remedy.
    (33) Cancer cure Cure and Remedy.
    (34) HIV/ AID Cure and Remedy.
    (35) Syphilis Cure and Remedy e.t.c....YOU CAN CONTACT ME WITH MY DETAILS BELOW, I WILL BE GLAD TO RENDER YOU MY HELP IF YOU HAVE ANY PROBLEM WHICH YOU NEED T SETTLE...
    WELCOME TO PRIEST OKEKE OF ITALIAN HEALING HOME
    THIS IS MY EMAIL ONCE AGAIN
    whatsapp  +256758348477
    www.onlinelovespells.com
    (profokeke7@gmail.com)

    ReplyDelete
  4. GET YOUR PROBLEM SOLVE TODAY WITH MY PROFESSION IN ANY SPIRITUAL SPELL, MY NAME IS PRIEST  OKEKE, AND THIS IS MY WHATSAPP   +  (EMAIL: profokeke7@gmail.com)
    ,I LIVE IN SOUTH AFRICA , AM ALWAYS AVAILABLE TO RENDER YOU HELP. WITH EXPERIENCE OF 80 YEARS IN SPELL CASTING AND HERBAL MEDICINE TO CURE ANY KIND OF DISEASE THAT YOU MAY HAVE, CONTACT ME ON ANY KIND OF ISSUES YOU MAY HAVE THAT IS BOTHERING YOU I CAN HELP YOU SOLVE PROBLEMS AS LISTED BELOW:www.onlinelovespells.com
    Whatsapp   +256758348477 
    (1) If you want your Divorced Husband/Wife back.
    (2) If you want your Ex Boyfriend/Girlfriend back.
    (3) If you always have Bad Dreams and you don't know the interpretations.
    (4) You want to be Promoted in your Office.
    (5) You want Women/Men to run after you.
    (6) If you want Children of your choice.
    (7) You want to be Rich Forever.
    (8) You want to tie your Husband/Wife to be yours forever.
    (9) Or you have been scammed and you want to Recover your Lost Money.
    (10) If you are in Love with Someone and you want Him/Her to fall in Love with you Totally.
    (12) If you want a Tame my Lover Spell.
    (13) If you want a Make Me Sexy Spell.
    (14) If you want a STOP His Roving Eyes Spell.
    (15) If you want a Rejuvenated Love Spell.
    (16) If you want a Be Faithful To Me Spell.
    (17) If you want to prevent or keep others from talking about my man.
    (18) Remove Bad Spells from Homes, Business & Customer Attraction etc.
    (19) Stop your Marriage or Relationship from Breaking Apart.
    (20) Read all your problems before you even mention them to me.
    (21) Remove the Back Spot that keeps on taking your Money Away.
    (22) Find out why you are not progressing in Life and the Solution.
    (23) Eliminate in family fights.
    (24) Ensure Excellent School Grades even for Children with Mental Disabilities.
    (25) Get promotion you have Desired for a Long Time at Work or in your Career.
    (26) Heal Barrenness in Women and Disturbing Menstruation.
    (27) Get you marriage to the Lover of your Choice.
    (28) Guarantee you Win the Troubling Court Cases.
    (39) Get the Spell to Win a Lottery.
    (30) Diabetes Cure and Remedy.
    (31) Herpes Cure and Remedy.
    (32) Hepatitis A, B, C Cure and Remedy.
    (33) Cancer cure Cure and Remedy.
    (34) HIV/ AID Cure and Remedy.
    (35) Syphilis Cure and Remedy e.t.c....YOU CAN CONTACT ME WITH MY DETAILS BELOW, I WILL BE GLAD TO RENDER YOU MY HELP IF YOU HAVE ANY PROBLEM WHICH YOU NEED T SETTLE...
    WELCOME TO PRIEST OKEKE OF ITALIAN HEALING HOME
    THIS IS MY EMAIL ONCE AGAIN
    whatsapp  +256758348477
    www.onlinelovespells.com
    (profokeke7@gmail.com)

    ReplyDelete
  5. GET YOUR PROBLEM SOLVE TODAY WITH MY PROFESSION IN ANY SPIRITUAL SPELL, MY NAME IS PRIEST  OKEKE, AND THIS IS MY WHATSAPP   +  (EMAIL: profokeke7@gmail.com)
    ,I LIVE IN SOUTH AFRICA , AM ALWAYS AVAILABLE TO RENDER YOU HELP. WITH EXPERIENCE OF 80 YEARS IN SPELL CASTING AND HERBAL MEDICINE TO CURE ANY KIND OF DISEASE THAT YOU MAY HAVE, CONTACT ME ON ANY KIND OF ISSUES YOU MAY HAVE THAT IS BOTHERING YOU I CAN HELP YOU SOLVE PROBLEMS AS LISTED BELOW:www.onlinelovespells.com
    Whatsapp   +256758348477 
    (1) If you want your Divorced Husband/Wife back.
    (2) If you want your Ex Boyfriend/Girlfriend back.
    (3) If you always have Bad Dreams and you don't know the interpretations.
    (4) You want to be Promoted in your Office.
    (5) You want Women/Men to run after you.
    (6) If you want Children of your choice.
    (7) You want to be Rich Forever.
    (8) You want to tie your Husband/Wife to be yours forever.
    (9) Or you have been scammed and you want to Recover your Lost Money.
    (10) If you are in Love with Someone and you want Him/Her to fall in Love with you Totally.
    (12) If you want a Tame my Lover Spell.
    (13) If you want a Make Me Sexy Spell.
    (14) If you want a STOP His Roving Eyes Spell.
    (15) If you want a Rejuvenated Love Spell.
    (16) If you want a Be Faithful To Me Spell.
    (17) If you want to prevent or keep others from talking about my man.
    (18) Remove Bad Spells from Homes, Business & Customer Attraction etc.
    (19) Stop your Marriage or Relationship from Breaking Apart.
    (20) Read all your problems before you even mention them to me.
    (21) Remove the Back Spot that keeps on taking your Money Away.
    (22) Find out why you are not progressing in Life and the Solution.
    (23) Eliminate in family fights.
    (24) Ensure Excellent School Grades even for Children with Mental Disabilities.
    (25) Get promotion you have Desired for a Long Time at Work or in your Career.
    (26) Heal Barrenness in Women and Disturbing Menstruation.
    (27) Get you marriage to the Lover of your Choice.
    (28) Guarantee you Win the Troubling Court Cases.
    (39) Get the Spell to Win a Lottery.
    (30) Diabetes Cure and Remedy.
    (31) Herpes Cure and Remedy.
    (32) Hepatitis A, B, C Cure and Remedy.
    (33) Cancer cure Cure and Remedy.
    (34) HIV/ AID Cure and Remedy.
    (35) Syphilis Cure and Remedy e.t.c....YOU CAN CONTACT ME WITH MY DETAILS BELOW, I WILL BE GLAD TO RENDER YOU MY HELP IF YOU HAVE ANY PROBLEM WHICH YOU NEED T SETTLE...
    WELCOME TO PRIEST OKEKE OF ITALIAN HEALING HOME
    THIS IS MY EMAIL ONCE AGAIN
    whatsapp  +256758348477
    www.onlinelovespells.com
    (profokeke7@gmail.com)

    ReplyDelete
  6. All my spells are genuinely proven .No spell has ever failed to bring about the desired effects. Best spells ever from the best experienced spell caster. We help where others have failed.
    I give 100% in every spell casting and as a professional I make sure all goes right. I give 100% to make you satisfied with my service. If you have a complex situation then I urge you to contact mewhatsapp +256758348477https://onlinelovespells.com* Want your lover back?
    * Attract a specific person
    * Spells to get married
    * Spells to help a relationship/ stop a divorce
    * Spells for bad luck and curse removals
    *Spells to boost your financial status
    * Spells for winning cases/Justice and gambling games e.g lotto
    Casino, and machines.
    * Even spells to get rid of an unwanted lover
    * And much more!
    * Have a serious problem that needs fixing?
    Any one of the following spells could quickly and dramatically change your life. And with our unconditional guarantee, you have nothing to lose.
    whatsapp +256758348477
    EM:profokeke7@gmail.com
    https://www.onlinelovespells.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. All my spells are genuinely proven .No spell has ever failed to bring about the desired effects. Best spells ever from the best experienced spell caster. We help where others have failed.
    I give 100% in every spell casting and as a professional I make sure all goes right. I give 100% to make you satisfied with my service. If you have a complex situation then I urge you to contact mewhatsapp +256758348477https://onlinelovespells.com* Want your lover back?
    * Attract a specific person
    * Spells to get married
    * Spells to help a relationship/ stop a divorce
    * Spells for bad luck and curse removals
    *Spells to boost your financial status
    * Spells for winning cases/Justice and gambling games e.g lotto
    Casino, and machines.
    * Even spells to get rid of an unwanted lover
    * And much more!
    * Have a serious problem that needs fixing?
    Any one of the following spells could quickly and dramatically change your life. And with our unconditional guarantee, you have nothing to lose.
    whatsapp +256758348477
    EM:profokeke7@gmail.com
    https://www.onlinelovespells.com

    ReplyDelete